Every game of the reign
| Belt game | Date | Result | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dec 14, 1949 | St. John's beat Kentucky 69–58 | Title change |
| 2 | Dec 18, 1949 | St. John's beat Washington State 67–44 | Defense |
| 3 | Dec 21, 1949 | St. John's beat San Francisco 60–44 | Defense |
| 4 | Dec 26, 1949 | St. John's beat Utah 51–50 | Defense |
| 5 | Jan 6, 1950 | St. John's beat Saint Joseph's 76–58 | Defense |
| 6 | Jan 12, 1950 | St. John's beat Georgetown 67–66 | Defense |
| 7 | Jan 16, 1950 | DePaul beat St. John's 74–68 | Title change |